Ted Merwin - Special To The
Jewish Week
They call him the greatest Jewish musician of the last half of
the 20th century, the most inspirational figure in Jewish life and
the savior of thousands of souls. Yet for all his tremendous energy
and charisma, the chasidic rabbi and singer Shlomo Carlebach was
also scorned by many in the Jewish establishment, seized by
self-doubt, and so focused on helping others that he seems to have
unhealthily repressed his own needs and desires.
When
“Shlomo, The House of Love and Prayer” begins its long-awaited first
workshop performances this weekend at the JCC in Manhattan,
audiences will be able to judge Rabbi Carlebach’s remarkable and
controversial legacy. Written and directed by Daniel Schechter and
David Wise, “Shlomo” stars the singer’s elder daughter, Neshama
Carlebach, who has become a major singing star in her own right in
the dozen years since her father’s death, with six albums of Jewish
music to date.
As Sandee Brawarsky reported in these pages
in 2005, the two-hour show follows Rabbi Carlebach from his
childhood in prewar Berlin through his family’s escape to New York,
where his father, Rabbi Naftali Carlebach took over the small
synagogue on West 79th Street that Shlomo and his brother, Eli
Chaim, later served.
The 18-member cast includes three
actors playing Rabbi Carlebach at different ages — Yitzhak Berkman,
Elliot Kranzler (known as “Elli”) and Dmitri Friedenberg. (Jason
Alexander, whom the producers approached to play Shlomo, turned down
the role.) Also featured in the cast is Grammy-nominated jazz singer
Carla Cook.
“Someone once told me that my father was blind in
that he only saw good in people,” Neshama told The Jewish Week in a
telephone interview. “I responded that my father sifted through
everything to find that one piece of good.” Yet she also said that
Orthodox rabbinical authorities “spit at him, literally and
figuratively” for his maverick approach to kiruv [outreach], which
offered unconditional love and acceptance to everyone and which
elevated women’s participation in Orthodox Judaism.
Much of
the show, which is a mix of concert and play, is set in the
eponymous house that Rabbi Carlebach founded in the Haight-Ashbury
neighborhood of San Francisco in the 1960s, in which he supported
Jewish hippies, drug addicts and runaways and allowed them to
experiment with drugs, sex, meditation, yoga and Eastern religions
while he brought them back to an awareness of their Jewish roots.
Wise, who just returned from producing a world tour of
“Rent,” said that his favorite moment in the show comes at the
beginning of Act 2, when Rabbi Carlebach, having been “exiled” by
the Lubavitch, is wandering through America feeling forlorn. He
hears the voice of Rebbe Nahman of Bratslav talking about living in
the forest and gathering people in the city until he collected the
whole nation. The scene ends with the other characters singing “Esa
Einai,” (I Will Lift Up My Eyes) in unison as they arrive at the
Berkeley Folk Festival in the late 1960s.
According to Wise,
Rabbi Carlebach was “a phoenix that helped the Jewish nation rise
from the ashes of the Holocaust.” He said that the show does not
seek to portray Rabbi Carlebach as a heroic figure, but rather to
ask how he managed to be a “rabbi and a rock star at the same time,
to have a broken heart and yet heal so many hearts, and to live with
so much irony, inconsistency and contradiction.”
Among Rabbi
Carlebach’s “inconsistency,” some have charged in recent years, was
a pattern of sexual harassment of female followers. But Wise
responds that Rabbi Carlebach simply “had no boundaries” and that
this enabled him to give so freely of his own material, emotional
and spiritual resources. Wise compared Rabbi Carlebach to Gospel
Highway kings like Sam Cooke and Otis Redding — performers who Wise
said greatly influenced Rabbi Carlebach —in his attainment of a
celebrity status that was exhilarating and seductive for men and
women alike, and that meant that there was simply “a different
reality when people were around him.”
In the end, Neshama
pointed out, her father tried to help ordinary people to reach their
own potential. “He wanted people to find out how they could make
their own mark on the world.” She expressed her hope that “people
will walk away seeing a whole new side to my father and thinking
that maybe their heart can be as big as his was.” n
“Shlomo,
The House of Love and Prayer,” will be performed at the JCC in
Manhattan, 334 Amsterdam Ave. at 76th Street. Performances are this
Sunday, Jan. 28 at 2 p.m. and 7 p.m., and Tuesday, Jan. 30 at 8 p.m.
For tickets, $36-$72, call Ticket Central at (212)
279-4200. |