THE HAPPIEST DAY OF THE YEAR

My grandparents first met each other on a September night at an Ann Arbor synagogue in 1934. They should have been inside davening the Kol Nidre service. Thank God, instead they chatted outside that shul. One thing led to another and forty two years later there was me. A holiday known as the Day of Judgment certainly doesn't evoke the same possibilities for romance as a more festive holiday like Purim, or Valentine's Day for that matter. But the timing of my Bubbe and Zayde's first meeting on Yom Kippur was not unprecedented.

The rabbis tell us that Yom Kippur and the Fifteenth of Av are the happiest days of the Jewish calendar. Why, you may ask? Of course we all feel closer to the Divine after having confessed the wrongs of the year and having resolved to be better in the year to come. Our spirits are naturally lifted when we are at peace with other people and with God. But the rabbis point to a custom of the Second Temple that at first seems to run counter to the spiritual nature of the day.

The young women of Jerusalem would dance in the vineyards on the afternoon of Yom Kippur. They would all wear borrowed white dresses so as not to embarrass the poorer of the lot. According to the rabbis (Taanit, 26b), the girls would say:
Young man, raise your eyes and behold what you choose for yourself. Do not set your eyes on beauty, but on a good family. "Grace is deceptive and beauty is vain; but a woman that fears the Lord, she shall be praised." (Proverbs 31:30)
We can explain this custom in several ways. The anthropological impulse is to explain it as a "mass mating" ritual, simply designed to carry on the race. After all, the ritual took place in a vineyard and occurred days before Sukkot, the fall harvest holiday. And certainly the emphasis on family over a pretty face points to the custom as part of a scheme to promote population growth.

But the emphasis on substance over flash also converges with the spiritual nature of the day. The thoughts of the repentant man should be on heavenly pursuits, not earthly ones. So when the bachelor chose his mate, it was with a clarity of purpose attained through prayer and fasting. As sexual contact is strictly prohibited on Yom Kippur, even those least affected by the spirit of the day were less likely to choose the material over the spiritual. During the afternoon prayer service of Yom Kippur, we read a selection from Leviticus that concerns forbidden marriages. Some argue that this was intended as further divine regulation on the courtship of the Jerusalem maidens.

The ritual of the dancing girls on Yom Kippur comes down to an issue common to the High Holidays in general: choice. Inherent in the notion of true repentance is the admission that a person can improve her or himself through personal choice, not simply through divine decree. The young women ask the young men to "choose for yourself." Contrary to the ways of the shtetl centuries later (where marriages were fixed by the families of the bride and groom), the decision is made by the individual, for better or worse.

So, why is Yom Kippur one of the happiest days of the year in the modern time, when nice Jewish boys (like me) don't have the advantage that men in Jerusalem did around the Second Temple? We learn from that custom the need for both God and love in our lives. If we can truly put our hearts into the meditations of Yom Kippur, we can achieve the clarity of vision to make even the most earthly of our decisions holy throughout the year to come.